Remove any Jibbitz before placing your Crocs in the boiling water. You don’t want to risk damaging those cuties! If both shoes won’t fit in the pot, you can soak them one at a time. Or you can place your Crocs in a sturdy plastic tote or bucket before carefully pouring boiling water over them. [3] X Research source

If you don’t own thick socks, you can put on 2 or 3 pairs of regular socks. [7] X Research source Place the straps behind your heels to keep your shoes in place. [8] X Research source Put your shoes on while they’re still hot, but not hot enough to cause burns. As much as you love your Crocs, they aren’t worth blistered feet! If your shoes haven’t stretched enough, give the boiling process another go. It might take a few tries to get the perfect fit.

If you don’t own thick socks, you can put on 2 or 3 pairs of regular socks. [12] X Research source Put your shoes on while they’re still hot, but not hot enough to cause burns. If you find yourself shouting “ouch,” wait a little longer. Place the straps behind your heels to keep your shoes in place while they stretch. [13] X Research source If your shoes haven’t stretched enough, don’t stress! Just repeat the drying process. It may take a few attempts to stretch your Crocs to the right size.

This method may give you a more custom fit because the shoe molds to the shape of your foot as it’s heated.